Sunday, May 15, 2022

moral dilemma

 



"God helps those who help themselves".  This passage is often represented as scripture - but in fact is not found anywhere in the Bible.  However, God will help those who take the first step of accepting Christ.  But asking for God's help is tricky business and how the help arrives is not always evident nor what may appear to be in a timely manner.

Recently a 66-year-old woman bought property right across the road from me.  I had notice someone "camping" on the 5 acre tract for 2 days so I contacted a local realtor to ask if someone had purchased the property.  I was told that "a very nice lady who used to live in Alpine bought it".  With that information, I went over to meet her and introduce myself.  There were numerous "red flags" popping up within minutes of talking to her.  She shared a lot of conflicting information about where she came from and told me she was planning on living there full time in a tent with no electricity.  I told her that was virtually impossible and at the very least she will need some kind of structure, some solar, and phone service in case of emergencies.  I also told her the vehicle she was driving was not at all appropriate for this area - a small black Hyundai sedan with highway tires and very low clearance.  It appeared to me that she has been living out of her car for some time.  She insisted she knew what she was doing and would be perfectly fine.

Over the course of a week, she spent the days just sitting in her black car with the doors open in 100+ degree daytime temperatures.  I don't think she even ran the engine to run the air conditioner (if it even worked).  She finally assembled a small tent on the third day but from what I could tell from that far away, I think she only used it to sleep in at night.  She didn't even have the ability to construct some shade over her vehicle with a dark grey tarp that she had.  A Brewster County Sheriff's Office deputy checked on her 3 times to try to convince her this was not a good idea.  He couldn't do anything else because she was on her own property.

So how can I help someone when they show absolutely no common sense for such a dire situation?   I'm talking none-zero-zilch.  I thought about this a lot.  Really the only thing I could have done for her was show her how to erect some shade over her car - but all she had was the dark grey tarp which would have been useless in providing any cooling.  Really - anything I could have done for this poor woman would have only enabled a hopeless situation.  That being said: after watching her spend her days just sitting in the black car with the doors open and wondering each morning if she was even still alive, I took her two gallons of chilled water late in the afternoon on her 5th day.  When I gave it to her, I bluntly said, "You have no business being out here.  You need to leave.  You are going to f*cking die out here because if you think it's hot now - just wait till it's over 110°!"   She just brushed it off and still insisted she was fine and asked me if I was going to town anytime soon.  I just walked away without answering her.  The next day she suffered through yet another day just sitting in her car (it got up to 103°).  

The following morning just as I was about to call Adult Protective Services, I saw her drive away.  APS investigates abuse, neglect, and exploitation of adults who are elderly or have disabilities and who live in the community.  Any adult who has a disability or is age 65 or older that is in a state of abuse, neglect or exploitation may be eligible to receive services - such as short-term shelter, home repairs, food, transportation, managing money, medical care, home healthcare services, and mental health services.  (I'm not sure if this woman is just naive, incredibly stupid, or has some mental health issues.)  Two days later, she was still gone but her tent had completely collapsed and there was a huge thunderstorm heading this way.  I was just going let it be as it was but decided to send a message to the realtor she bought the property from.  Not knowing if this women was ever coming back for the stuff she left on the property, I told the realtor if she was in contact with the women to tell her that I am going to go collect her tent and her belongings and bring them back to my place for safe keeping in case the storm hits and that she can stop by and collect the items when she comes back.  

So the storm ended up petering out and we just got a sprinkle.  Early that evening, two deputies showed up at my place and the woman was back at her property.  She had gotten the message I sent to the realtor and asked the deputy to come get her stuff from me.  The deputies both agreed with my assessment of her situation but at this point there was still nothing they could do about it.  He also told me that the women said she wanted nothing more to do with me (not a thank you for saving her stuff from the storm).  It should be noted that had the storm hit, most likely neither the woman nor the deputies would have even been able to make it out my road that evening.

The deputies left and a little while later the woman drove off and didn't return until sometime later that night.  So now we are up to yesterday.  She spent the entire day just sitting in her black car yet again (got up to 102°) - without bothering to put her tent back up.  This morning she drove off after putting up a no trespassing sign next to her pile of a tent and whatever else she left there.  I have no idea what her plans are at this point.  Perhaps she got the message?   I guess I will try calling APS if she returns.  How her help arrives certainly may not be immediately evident to her, but hopefully it will be timely enough to save her life.

12 comments:

JudithK said...

You have done what you could, and it was a lot. More than many people would have done.A good Samaritan is sometimes not well received. I don't know what else to say. You will most likely watch and see if there is a time when something you can actually help with.
Often that's all a person can do. But you know that.

Hachita said...

That is so sad. Your vigilance may help yet. Hard to see how folks can reach such an extreme, unable to admit it or accept kindness.
Paris, Texas

Marvey Hushman said...

It's very hard to help people with mental health issues. I have an elderly lady next door that I clear snow for from her sidewalk and driveway. Also, cut the grass. She never acknowledges me except for an occasional glare. And we get over 90 inches of snow here each winter. It's no small amount of effort to clear off her place. The cops check on her once in awhile. I think she's just waiting to "kick the bucket" at this point.

remmij said...

is that right on the edge of your old airfield?… you could always use the Mavic to check on her…
you can lead a horse to water… don't end up getting yourself arrested & sued… odder things have happened

remmij said...

Aokigahara? - the treeless Terlingua version

LeoinSA said...

Ah... I've thought about this dilemma a lot since I first read it.

Based on what you have written...

You've done the best possible, given... the refusal of help.

I strongly lean toward personal responsibility. If you are so mentally unstable to comprehend, and want to live in a extreme desert climate without suitable preparations...

Then Darwin, survival of the most prepared and adaptable, will prevail.

Please call so that the authorities remove the body.

You've done the best as any individual can do.

Michael D. Berry said...

This woman has dementia. Some of her actions are similar to my 92 year old mother's. We took Mom to a memory care facility now 5 weeks ago because she was not taking care of herself (meds, bathing, etc). She was pretty upset with me for driving her out there (230 miles nearer my sister). 2 weeks later she could not walk from her bed to her apartment door. Low blood oxygen was the diagnosis. Ambulance called. Three days in the hospital she was fine and lost 20 lbs of fluid weight that was on her heart and lungs. Moving her there saved her life. Her cardiologist appointment was already scheduled back at home after this incident. All things equal she would have been found by my brother when he checked on her after work and likely would have died.
She still doesn't think she needs help (similar to this lady) but seems more acclimated to her new environment. If there is a memory care facility in Alpine or Marfa maybe they can refer you to a specialist who can help the authorities with what they need to legally to get her to a safer place.

LeoinSA said...

@Michael D. Berry

I do not disagree with anything your wrote.

But the question, at least as I see it, is whether it is John's responsibility to do more?

I say not. The county sheriff has attended. What happens now? Dunno.

John Wells said...

If she comes back out and I call APS and they do nothing, then I've done all I can do. All that leaves for me is to call 911 when she dies.

MsBelinda said...

What a sad case poor lady is definitively not mentally well. I think you have done all that you could. If she bought the lot, she had to have money to have paid for it, so she is not destitute. I hope that if she returns she does not perish in these hellacious temperatures.

John Wells said...

A lot of people come out here spending their last dime on property thinking they've got it made - until they discover how much more it is going to cost to get set up just to survive.

Russ Smith said...

One more thing: Prayer. Prayer that APS can/will help her. That she sees her error and heads for town. That her family will find her and get her the help she needs. That John doesn't have to trespass to see why buzzards are hanging around.

Prayers for you too John, that's a tough situation to be in. You may be the only person in the world who cares anything about her. And at the same time, you don't really want to be her enabler. I don't envy your situation.